who should be moved up from the list and who should be moved downward ?

Best Comic Book Writers of All-Time
List items

1. Alan Moore

2. Grant Morrison

3. Stan Lee

4. Frank Miller

5. Brian K. Vaughan

6. Geoff Johns

7. Neil Gaiman

8. Mark Waid

9. Warren Ellis

10. Ed Brubaker

11. Garth Ennis

12. Jack Kirby

13. Marv Wolfman

14. Will Eisner

15. Brian Michael Bendis

16. Jonathan Hickman

17. Jason Aaron

18. Mark Millar

19. Robert Kirkman

20. Scott Snyder

21. Greg Rucka

22. Jeff Lemire

23. Rick Remender

24. Kieron Gillen

25. Matt Wagner

26. Kurt Busiek



27. Matt Fraction

28. Chris Claremont

29. Mike Mignola

30. John Byrne

31. Brian Azzarello

32. Jeph Loeb

33. Jim Starlin

34. Dennis O'Neil

35. Gardner Fox

36. Jim Shooter

37. Otto Binder

38. Roy Thomas

39. Darwyn Cooke

40. Daniel Clowes

41. James Robinson

42. Jaime Hernandez

43. Peter David

44. Roy Thomas

45. Roger Stern

46. Steve Gerber

47. Peter Milligan

48. Steve Englehart

49. John Ostrander

50. J.M. DeMatteis

51. Dan Slott

52. Walter Simonson

53. Gail Simone

54. Carl Barks

55. Keith Giffen

56. Dave Sim

57. Art Spiegelmen

This was from Comic Vine ( not my personal list )

[comicvine.gamespot.com]

Fore sure --- Grant Morrison needs to move down a bit.

Denny O'Neil , Peter David and Roy Thomas need to be moved up the list

I'd put Geoff Johns at number 1

Walter Simonson and Brian Michael Bendis are too low

W. Simonson agreed has to move up but I can see being a well known artist shaved off some points perception wise.

Bendis at 15 is pretty good. He ended up spamming scripts - his output in his heyday was even more than Chris Claremont . So a lot of mediocre comics got churned out. But I would put him high on the list too.

this top 50 artist and writer has him at number 12

[www.cbr.com]


Interesting Alan Moore and Grant Morrison are 1 and 2 on both lists.